Skip to content
Advertisement

Shelton provides response to resolution over Board Member complaint

Note: the following item was submitted by Austyn Shelton for publication in response to the resolution of the complaint he submitted. It has been left as it was submitted. Polk Today welcomes any comment from Jeff Hawkins or other board members about the matter, and will allow those to be made publicly available without charge. […]

Note: the following item was submitted by Austyn Shelton for publication in response to the resolution of the complaint he submitted. It has been left as it was submitted. Polk Today welcomes any comment from Jeff Hawkins or other board members about the matter, and will allow those to be made publicly available without charge.

–KtE


Polk County Educator Speaks Out Following Board of Education’s Decision to Cancel Hearing Into Allegations Against Board Member Jeff Hawkins

October 9, 2026 — POLK COUNTY, GA — My name is Austyn Shelton, and I am a fourth-grade teacher at Westside Elementary School in the Polk School District. I am speaking publicly regarding serious allegations of misconduct involving District 5 Board of Education member Jeff Hawkins and the Board’s October 9th decision to cancel a previously scheduled public hearing concerning those allegations.

My Response to Today’s Board of Education Vote Concerning The Ethics Complaints Made Against Jeff Hawkins:

Following the filing of formal ethics complaints, the Polk County Board of Education scheduled a public hearing for October 12, 2026, to consider the ethics allegations involving Board of Education Mr. Jeff Hawkins. I was prepared for that hearing to proceed.

Today, October 9, 2026, I was informed that the Board had voted to approve an offer of resolution stating that the Board Chair would read at the next regular Board meeting:

“Now that the Board has accepted Mr. Hawkins’ Offer of Resolution, the Board would like to remind Mr. Hawkins that, as an elected public official, he, just like every member of this Board, is expected to maintain the highest standard of professional conduct and uphold public trust. Mr. Hawkins is hereby reminded that he should take no private action that will compromise the Board or school system administration. When problems, complaints, or operational issues are brought to your attention, you must follow the established Board procedures, the Board’s Code of Ethic’s Policy, and chain of command to have those issues addressed. Respecting this process ensures that this Board can address concerns fairly, consistently, and effectively for the betterment of our students, staff, parents, and community.”

Additionally, as part of the offer of resolution, so that the public ethics hearing against him scheduled for Monday, October 12th would be cancelled, Mr. Hawkins agreed:

  • Not to challenge the statement from the Board Chair or designee reading the above statement at the next regular Board meeting.
  • Make an open-session statement expressing his belief in the quality of education at Westside Elementary School and affirming his confidence in its staff, teachers, and leadership.
  • Agreed to recuse himself from personnel actions involving me and Westside Elementary Principal Laura Little for one year.

I find this resolution profoundly disappointing. What is important to know is that Mr. Hawkins refused to a settlement offer that included him agreeing to cease and desist disparaging us in the future, permanently recusing himself from personnel matters involving myself and my Principal Laura Little, and refused to agree to a settlement which would prevent him from retaliating against us in the future despite the fact the law prohibits him from retaliation.  Notably, Mr. Hawkins did not agree to our proposed offer despite the fact he would have obtained a release of all claims against him if he had simply agreed not to retaliate, to cease and desist from disparagement of us, and to permanently recuse himself.

I believe these were reasonable requests. If the goal was to resolve the dispute and prevent future disparagement and retaliation occurring against the educators of Polk County School District, why could the agreement not include a lasting commitment to refrain from disparagement or retaliation?

Why should protection from his participation in personnel decisions involving us last only one year where Mr. Hawkins would be free to retaliate against me? Is Mr. Hawkins simply concerned with trying to run a statute of limitations deadlines? Does he not understand that if he retaliates against any educator who courageously exercises their First Amendment rights to free speech or opposes his violations of laws, rules, and regulations that he will be held liable?

These are questions I believe deserve answers.

Concerns About Accountability and Transparency

I was also informed that, during the Board’s consideration of the proposal, certain Board members expressed concerns about whether the complainants could pursue further action if the hearing was cancelled. According to the account provided to me, the Board’s attorney assured them that we could not. This is not accurate. If Mr. Hawkins shows malice against me by defaming my good name and professional reputation, I know that the Georgia Association of Educators will be holding him in him liable. He will not be able to hide behind an veil of official immunity and will be individually liable for all retaliatory actions made against employees of this District in violation of the law.

This Is About More Than One Teacher

I believe members of the Board of Education should be held to a high standard of professionalism, fairness, and accountability.

Board members are elected to serve the students, employees, families, and communities of Polk County.

They should not use their positions in ways that intimidate educators or undermine students’ confidence in their teachers.

If a board member has legitimate concerns about a teacher’s performance, established administrative and evaluation procedures exist to address those concerns.

Elementary school children should not be placed in the middle of disagreements involving adults, particularly when those disagreements concern their own teachers. Disturbing allegations have been made to me concerning Mr. Hawkins (man who has never spoken to me a day in his life or ever set foot in my classroom) that if true, would mean he violated the law and his Board ethics.

On July 26, 2026, I received a telephone call from the parent of two former students. The parent informed me that the children had recently returned from a 14-day trip with Mr. Hawkins. According to the parent, the children reported that Mr. Hawkins had brought copies of the third- and fourth-grade curriculum on the trip and repeatedly questioned them about academic material. The parent reported that Mr. Hawkins criticized my teaching–statements which would constitute defamation per se–and that amongst his false statements reported to me, disturbingly threatened: “Come January, after the new election, I’ll have another board member on my side, and I want him fired.”

My Professional Record and Commitment to Students

Throughout my teaching career, my students’ academic performance has consistently been a source of pride. My stellar performance evaluations and track record reflect such. My classroom test results have been as strong as, and in many instances stronger than, those achieved elsewhere across the Polk School District.

I welcome an objective review of my student achievement data and instructional performance. My results should be evaluated using actual academic evidence, not statements allegedly made in private conversations with children. I also have had multiple evaluations over my four years and never once received a score of less than satisfactory. I am grateful to have such supportive supervisors and a school Principal who supported me 100 percent and defended me from these false allegations.

One of my greatest strengths as an educator is my ability to build meaningful relationships with students. That does not stop with the children assigned to my classroom. I work to establish positive relationships with every student I encounter. I believe students learn best when they feel respected, supported, valued, and safe. Building relationships with children is not a weakness in education. It is an essential part of effective teaching. Being kind to students does not mean I lack classroom expectations. Being approachable does not mean I fail to provide rigorous instruction. The suggestion that my students receive grades they have not earned is not only unfair to me as an educator; it is also unfair to the children who work hard every day to achieve academic success.

Educators are evaluated, questioned, and held accountable for their work regularly, and that is appropriate. I filed my complaint because I believe there is a fundamental difference between legitimate professional oversight and the malicious defamatory remarks that were reported to me as being made repeatedly by Mr. Hawkins.

I also believe that when an educator raises concerns about the conduct of an elected official, those concerns deserve a fair, transparent, and meaningful review.

My Message to the Polk County Community

I love my profession. I love my students. I am proud to teach in the Polk School District.

I will continue showing up every day, providing quality instruction, maintaining high expectations, and building positive relationships with the children entrusted to my care.

I am not asking the community to accept every allegation as proven fact. I am asking the community to understand what was reported, why it raised serious concerns, and why I believe Mr. Hawkin’s response was insufficient.

I respect the importance of due process, including Mr. Hawkins’ right to respond to allegations made against him. That is one reason I believed the scheduled hearing was important.

A statement expressing confidence in teachers is appreciated, but it is not a substitute for meaningful accountability. A one-year recusal does not resolve my concerns about what happens after that year expires. And cancelling a hearing does not erase the allegations that led to it being scheduled.

I believe the citizens of Polk County deserve transparency from their elected officials, and educators deserve to know they can raise legitimate concerns without fear of retaliation.

My hope is that bringing these concerns to the public’s attention will encourage a serious conversation about accountability, professionalism, and the standards we expect from those elected to lead our schools.

Austyn Shelton
Fourth-Grade Teacher
Westside Elementary School
Polk School District

This statement reflects my personal views and experiences. I am speaking in my individual capacity as a private citizen of Polk County and not on behalf of Westside Elementary School or in my official capacity as an educator of the Polk School District.

Leave a Reply

+
⛶
×
Polk Today
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.